By Neil Lancaster https://neillancastercrime.co.uk/
Published by HQ Digital (an impress of Harper Collins Publishers) https://www.hqstories.co.uk/
384 pages ISBN 9780008518479
Publication date 8 September 2022
The Night Watch is the third novel in the Max Craigie series.
I was allowed access to a pdf review copy on Net Galley. Thanks to the author and publisher for organising this.
From the blurb
He’ll watch you.
A lawyer is found dead at sunrise on a lonely clifftop at Dunnet Head on the northernmost tip of Scotland. It was supposed to be his honeymoon, but now his wife will never see him again.
He’ll hunt you.
The case is linked to several mysterious deaths, including the murder of the lawyer’s last client – Scotland’s most notorious criminal… who had just walked free. DS Max Craigie knows this can only mean one thing: they have a vigilante serial killer on their hands.
He’ll leave you to die.
But this time the killer isn’t on the run; he’s on the investigation team. And the rules are different when the murderer is this close to home.
He knows their weaknesses, knows how to stay hidden, and he thinks he’s above the law…
Synopsis
‘Not Proven’ the infuriating third verdict possible in Scotland allows Scott ‘The Axe’ Paterson to strut out of court cocksure and a free man. Few would shed a tear when he is found murdered on a golf course, but when his lawyer is also found dead off a cliff top through either accident or suicide, people take note. DS Craigie fears that there is a vigilante killer out there intent on righting the wrongs of the legal system, with their own brand of tough justice.
When that rarest of commodities in the modern world, a hard drinking old-school investigative journalist Shuggie Gibson approaches with inside information Max’s team take note. Shuggie has an informant, who seems to be reliable, who points in the direction of an MIT officer. An unpleasant task ahead, but just the sort of job the Policing Standards Reassurance team was set up for.
To progress the investigation, they need someone on the inside, luckily Max knows just the person for the job. With their mole in place and ex MI5 man Barney working on the surveillance hardware Max is confident of getting a result, but ultimately will the price they have to pay prove too great?
My thoughts
Before you dive into The Night Watch fasten your seatbelt because it doesn’t hang around. Perhaps not quite as fast paced as The Blood Tide (reviewed here) it retains all the hallmarks of the author’s fast past paced all action-packed style. A book where the action drags the reader along with it.
The plot centres on police corruption, but this time not the financial kind but the moral kind. Law enforcement officers taking the law into their own hands when the ‘right’ judgement is not delivered, handing out summary executions. Nobody wants to live in a country where the police force also acts as judge and executioner, like in a few failed states, but one can appreciate the frustration when a prosecution fails, and the accused is laughing at the officers. So, something very rare but not entirely far-fetched.
Even though the novel is incident packed there is time for some excellent characterisation. We learn more of Max’s time in the Met and how he owes his friend and former colleague Niall Hastings so much. A debt that becomes central to the plot. Max is still suffering with PTSD, the insomnia and nightmares, and how mages to cope. We also get to know that finally Janie’s relationship problems are being resolved as she settles down with new girlfriend Melissa. Not forgetting the third member of the team Ross who is still being moulded by his wife (surely, she cannot remain a ‘her indoors’ style character throughout the series.) There is also a lovely cameo portrayal of Shuggie the decent old-school journalist, a dying breed in the age of clickbait online ‘journalism.’
As already noted, the storyline doesn’t hang around, but Mr Lancaster maintains a canny knack of remaining one step ahead of the reader the whole time. Just when you think it’s becoming clear where the plot is leading there is a sidestep and like a labouring prop forward in the loose you are left in his wake trying to catch up. Some readers may be quicker on the uptake, but I was guessing right up to the end.
The thing that makes it all work is the authentic feel about it. As fiction the boundaries are going to be pushed in the name of entertainment, but at its core this is a novel written by an author who has first hand experience and knows how to bring this to life on the page. Even down to Max’s PTSD, if the author hasn’t suffered himself, I would imagine he has encountered those who have. Sadly as a nation we put young in the firing line to protect us but fail to do enough to protect them on their return.
There are two central themes to the novel. The first is the vigilantism, the killing of evil people who ‘get away with it’. The other is the bond of friendship forged during danger that can never fully be repaid, the reliance on someone even to put them back in danger. Undercover work is glamourised in fiction, particularly on screen, but the human cost on an individual level is so great. The question posed s when have you had enough, when do you get out? Powerful stuff.
The Night Watch is a high-octane crime thriller that feels truly authentic that will have you engrossed from the start and exhausted by then end. Enjoy the ride!
The author
NEIL LANCASTER is the No. 1 digital bestselling author of both the Tom Novak and Max Craigie series. His first Craigie novel, Dead Man’s Grave, was longlisted for the 2021 McIlvanney Prize for Best Scottish Crime Book of the Year. The second Craigie novel, The Blood Tide, topped several ebook and audio charts. It was also longlisted for the 2022 McIlvanney Prize and shortlisted for Best New Series at the Dead Good Reader Awards.
Neil’s authentic crime writing style stems from his police background. He served as a military policeman and worked for the Metropolitan Police as a detective, investigating serious crimes in the capital and beyond. As a covert policing specialist, he used all manner of techniques to investigate and disrupt major crime and criminals. He now lives in the Scottish Highlands, writes crime and thriller novels and works as a broadcaster and commentator on true crime documentaries. He is an expert on two Sky Crime TV series, Meet, Marry, Murder and Made for Murder.